Last summer I read All Can Be Saved by the eminent historian of colonial Latin America, Stuart Schwartz. It’s a…
Beyond Religious Freedom
Beyond Religious Freedom: The New Global Politics of Religion is a study of recent state-led efforts to promote religious freedom, religious engagement, and the rights of religious minorities internationally. Elizabeth Shakman Hurd brings together the study of contemporary religion and the study of global politics to chart these projects and their context and to develop a better understanding of their consequences for both politics and religion.
Hurd challenges the claim that the legalization of freedom of religion, state-sponsored religious engagement, and legal protections for religious minorities emancipate society from persecution and discrimination. Instead, she shows how these efforts exacerbate social tensions by making religious difference a matter of law, enacting a divide between the religion of those in power and the religion of those without it. This leads to a politics defined by religious difference and favors forms of religion authorized by those in positions of power. It also obscures other factors that contribute to discrimination and violence.
The book does not argue “against” religious freedom—instead, it asks: what are the effects of constructing a legal regime around “religious freedom” and a discursive world around that? Does it advance or impede efforts to live together across deep lines of difference, which are often accompanied by persistent and multiplex forms of inequality? Advocates of religious freedom presume that the answer is self-evident and affirmative. Hurd sees the answer as more complex and the outcome as much less utopian.
In this series, scholars from across the disciplines engage with and respond to Hurd’s work.
Engaging the R word
As it promises on the dust jacket, Elizabeth Shakman Hurd’s Beyond Religious Freedom delivers a critique of the politics of promoting…
Religious freedom, past and future
For those of us who have been following the Politics of Religious Freedom project on this website and elsewhere, Beyond…
The pathologies of religious freedom
In the preface to his 1947 essay, Humanism and Terror: An Essay on the Communist Problem, French philosopher Maurice Merleau-Ponty…
A salutary tremor
What logics, strategies, and effects characterize the category of religion as an instrument for governing social life? What possibilities and…
A more anxious freedom
Elizabeth Shakman Hurd's Beyond Religious Freedom: The New Global Politics of Religion is notable for its subtlety and intellectual generosity, as…
The uncertainty principles of Heisenberg and Hurd
In the late 1920s, the theoretical physicist Werner Heisenberg wrote a series of scientific papers proposing that the universe could…
The new global politics of religion: A view from the other side
In the summer of 2013, the international Islamic magazine al-Bayan published its Ramadan issue with a striking cover. Flanked by…
Paradoxes of international religious freedom
It has been almost twenty years since the US Congress passed the International Religious Freedom Act (IRFA), which was signed…
Rethinking religion in a political scientific wilderness
Beyond Religious Freedom: The New Global Politics of Religion makes an extremely important and timely contribution to a conversation that…