Most sociologists of religion seem to agree on two things. First, that the growth of interest in religion---in academia, the…
Sociology of religion
Based on an extensive survey and rigorous quantitative analysis, David Smilde and Matthew May conclude that, over the last thirty years, sociologists have increasingly come to figure religion as an “independent variable having causal impact,” suggesting the emergence of a “strong program” in the sociology of religion. This dramatic transformation, they argue, calls for sustained critical reflection on the evolving state of the sub-discipline.
Read Smilde and May’s “The Emerging Strong Program in the Sociology of Religion.”
Following this SSRC working paper’s publication, along with a subsequent manifesto calling for a “new sociology of religion”—by Courtney Bender, Wendy Cadge, Peggy Levitt, and David Smilde—several other sociologists have joined the conversation. Browse all posts in this discussion below.
Toward a new sociology of religion
Many sociologists of religion have voiced the concern that the sub-discipline is "in crisis." Others bemoan what they view as…
Getting out of crisis-mode
Although the sociology of religion is in a relatively good state, it still seems that there is continuing intellectual insecurity…
The promise and limits of the sociology of religion
According to [the assesments of Smilde and May and Levitt et al.], sociology of religion is not in crisis, but…
The pig is not the problem
Regardless of their stance on secularization, both classical and market-based positions take modernity for granted as the starting point for…
Giving the strong program a critical edge
In these comments I want to point to another angle on the tendency to emphasize the positive aspects of religion—one…
Not much has changed—and should it?
We need to be clear about what is happening in the field before advocating for any specific changes. To that…
The (really) strong program
Whenever there is talk about an ‘emerging strong program’ and ‘a new sociology of religion,’ we need to keep in…
A call for sustained epistemological work
I would like to suggest that sociology, and particularly sociology of religion, can benefit greatly from a thorough examination of…
Sybil and the strong, silent type
Appearing at the same time as a manifesto for expanding American sociologists’ approaches to religion, Smilde and May’s report is…